Ask The Brewmasters

 View Only
  • 1.  Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-28-2025 19:27

    Hello everyone:

    We have been running a single head Codi machine for the last 6 million cans, we replace the chuck and rollers annually, de-shim the rollers every 300k cans. and have rebuild the main bearing 3 times. 

    However, something in my seam reports has always troubled me. 

    we run a standard 12-ounce can with a 202-CDL Lid and need to run the seamer so tight that Op-2 nearly collides with the chuck in order to get anything close to the ball seam specs of .041 to .045. 

    the reason for this is the angle of the lid itself in relation to the can wall. in the picture below you will see that this translates as a large cone shaped gap leading into the seam. is this gap normal with this lid type? are balls specs just overkill on purpose? or is this simply an issue of not having a hearty enough machine to do the process justice?

     

    please note the picture below 

    width measurement adjusted to the ideal position

    thanks for any input you may have. 



    ------------------------------
    Michael Smith
    Head Brewer
    Eel River Brewing Co.
    Fortuna, CA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-29-2025 15:19
      |   view attached
    Michael,
     
    At first glance, it appears that the chuck and Operation (Op) profile are not correctly matched for the seam you're attempting to make, or there may be a mismatch between the chuck profile and the end type you're using. I agree that the profile of the end material shown in your image looks quite different from what I would expect, extending outward at a steep angle.
     
    I've attached a resource that has been immensely helpful for us when troubleshooting seam specification issues on our Codi CCL-45. We use Ball ends and adhere to the same specifications, targeting a 0.045 in. thickness.
     
    Adjusting the Op height relative to the chuck can influence this profile relationship and the shape of the seam pocket, though I doubt it could correct for such a drastic change in end geometry.
     
    For testing, you can perform an Op 1-only run on the Codi by physically removing the entire Op 2 mounting block from the post (one set screw and two clamping bolts). Be sure not to lose the spacer ring above the block or the shaft key during removal.
     
    Regarding the Op roller contacting the chuck - that's likely causing significant wear and other issues, including damage to the Op roller bearings, main chuck/drive bearings, and possible deformation of the chuck profile itself.
     
    Do you also measure countersink depth during your seam inspections? If so, are those measurements within Ball's published specifications?


    ------------------------------
    Brandt Stewart Dipl. Brew
    Director of Brewing Operations
    Third Space Brewing
    Milwaukee WI
    (414) 909-2337 x40
    ------------------------------

    Attachment(s)

    pdf
    Grace Seam Manual Updated.pdf   4.51 MB 1 version


  • 3.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-30-2025 16:45

    thanks for the responses so far everyone. 

    Brandt:

    The grace manual is the best I've seen so far, thank you. 

    do you mind sharing the following info if its readily available.

    do you use the CDL-lid?

    can you provide your chuck and roller numbers?

    can you provide your gap settings?

    if you prefer you can email me directly. 

    Brewer@eelriverbrewing.com.

     



    ------------------------------
    Michael Smith
    Head Brewer
    Eel River Brewing Co.
    Fortuna, CA
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-29-2025 15:20
    Michael,
    In terms of the gap, it is normal for lightweighted lids since the panel diameter is smaller. See the attached overlay for reference. 
    I would recommend you adjust to get more cover hook and more body hook.  As you know, this will increase your overlap and give you a better nights rest!


    Best Regards,


    David Garab, Founder/COO

    PREFERRED SEAMER SERVICE, LLC

    c 404-234-4188


    "You Can't Sell Leakers"





  • 5.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-30-2025 15:28

    I have an early version of the CODI seamer guidelines and for OP 2 if gives lateral spacing specs of .002"-.005" .In the side notes it says "for op2 you can bring the OP into the chuck and then back it out until you see a sliver of day light coming through." So yeah, you're going to get close to that chuck! 



    ------------------------------
    Amber Sawicki
    Head Brewer
    Boomtown Brewing
    Los Angeles CA
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-31-2025 15:20

    Hey Michael - best to confirm if you have the correct chucks for the 202 CDL+ lids.  Chuck fit is critical for getting a good seam and if you were running different lids before CDL+ the chuck wall angle may be off.  Based on the profile above, I would be worried about product egressing out.  David G. is correct in driving that body hook longer to get better overlap.  We internally try to run our seams with a much larger overlap that what you have above.  Happy to have further discussions if you want  



    ------------------------------
    Eric Samp PhD
    Director of Manufacturing Excellence
    New Belgium / Bells
    720-201-6973
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 10-31-2025 19:41

    Here's the most recent Ball CDL spec sheet we use. Verify the end thickness and coating from your supplier.



    ------------------------------
    Brent Acomb
    Packaging Manager
    Mother Road Brewing Co
    Flagstaff AZ
    (951) 764-0074
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 11-03-2025 14:35

    Awesome: 

    thank you so much Brent for the new seam spec sheet. 

    it reveals much more of the puzzle than what I was looking at based on a 20 year old spec sheet I got from my supplier. 

    one more question for you guys before I'm back to cutting and scanning. 

    on the new spec sheet for seam thickness, it mentions (.0082"g - .0085"g) is this the liner thickness in the can, the lid, or something else?

      



    ------------------------------
    Michael Smith
    Head Brewer
    Eel River Brewing Co.
    Fortuna, CA
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Codi Canning Machine Seams

    Posted 11-03-2025 15:36
    Michael,
    "Eight two" and "eight five" is the nominal lid gauge (thickness). 

    You would need to consult your lid supplier if using a 3rd party, since the original pallet ticket from the manufacturer is removed. On the original pallet ticket you would see 82 or 85 numerically in the shorthand. 

    Bottom line, 2nd op seam thickness guidelines depend on which gauge you have. 


    Best Regards,


    David Garab, Founder/COO

    PREFERRED SEAMER SERVICE, LLC

    c 404-234-4188


    "You Can't Sell Leakers"