Dear Fellow Brewer
I'm sorry to read of this situation.
Although not uncommon it is none the less scary. Most of us have been there but we don't like to talk about it.
It often happens in the fall after a long, hot summer. Especially in certain beer styles with low hopping, unfiltered, low ABV, low attenuation, or higher pH etc. Weiss Bier, Amber Fest Beer etc
Your plan is certainly not "overkill"
It is the only rational course of action.
You are right to suspect the sample valve. These should be strip cleaned every time the tank is emptied for CIP. We autoclave these valves after every use as Zwickels are a real weak point. But also look for the ultimate source. Check the instruments that you attached to this sample port. For example, Z-N CO2 Tester or other CO2/DO instrument. They can get really dirty. You actually need to develop a CIP program for your instruments! This is especially true in the fall after a hot and humid summer when such events are very common. Other weak points are the various rubber good on tank fittings - for example, at level transmitters, butterfly valves. PRV's etc. Bourdon style (non-sanitary!!) pressure gauges with NPT ends are notoriously bad (use should really outlaw them in your brewery)!! Check the tank itself for presence of beer stone that indicates incomplete CIP and/or insufficient brewing water treatment. UV Lamps as are found at Dairy Equipment supply houses are helpful for spotting low levels of stone. Beer/Milk stone fluoresce in such light. Lastly, bring along some test tubes of saline with sterile swabs so you can swab all suspect surfaces as you find them. Plate these on relevant media. This helps you identify the ultimate source and a great way to learn how to avoid a repeat next fall! Keep the offending bug in your library so you know if it shows up again. L. brevis, for example.
Good Luck,
------------------------------
Daniel Carey
Brewmaster
New Glarus Brewing Company
New Glarus WI
(608) 527-5850
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-10-2022 17:50
From: Anonymous Member
Subject: Best practices for CIP following infection in a tank
This message was posted by a user wishing to remain anonymous
We recently had plates sampled from one of our brite tanks show substantial growth on UBA and LMDA plates (showing substantial acid production by the CFUs). We immediately scrapped plans to package this beer. Subsequently our Lab Manager re-plated and again saw rampant growth on LMDA both aerobically and anaerobically. Isolated CFUs were stained and diastase test performed. Under the microscope the bacteria appeared to be rod-shaped and gram-positive leading us to believe that it was Lactobacillus. Additionally, we inoculated HLP media with samples from this brite tank and they returned with substantial colonies of comet-like CFUs…also indicating Lactobacillus. We then sent samples to our yeast supplier to run PCR and they confirmed the presence of hop tolerant Lactobacillus. We have plans to destroy this beer (despite evidence now showing that the infection is isolated to the sample valve…but more on that later). So, I'd like to run through my plans to safely remediate this infection and get your feedback. ALL other tanks in the cellar have come back clean and free of contamination, with repeated platings on LMDA and HLP.
My plan is to use 1/2" tubing run to our drain to slowly drain the tank so as not to tax our wastewater. Once drained we will acid wash, then fully de-gas, fully evacuate the tank of CO2, then run a caustic cycle. All gaskets will be replaced. Post CIP we will confirm cleaning with an ATP swab. Once passed, the tank will then get filled with water which will be pushed out of the tank to fully purge the vessel and rid it of most of the oxygen. The tank will then be sanitized under pressure using PAA to the appropriate strength.
Does this course of action seem sufficient? Overkill? Just right? Suggestions on a better course of action? We have been fortunate to have never encountered this issue before and hopefully won't ever again.
Getting back to the sample valve…it is a Perlick-style valve with rubber cup seal, rather than the old school swivel style zwickel. A subsequent plating on LMDA and HLP of a sample taken from the bottom of the tank showed zero growth. Absolutely clean. Obviously this points to bacterial build up in the sample valve gasket AND/Or introduction of hop tolerant lactobacillus THROUGH the sample valve, most likely from an over-pressurized and contaminated Zahm. So, the follow up question here is… is there anyone out there sanitizing their Zahm prior to use? How are you doing so? Other than a few gaskets on the interior of the Zahm, would their be any reason we couldn't or shouldn't pack the Zahm in iodine-based sanitizer or PAA? Is there a "best practices" article regarding Zahm cleaning, maintenance, use, and sanitation?